I’m not very old, so I realize I haven’t seen a large number of presidential elections, but my sense is that we have perhaps never (or at least rarely) found ourselves in the same kind of political climate as we find ourselves today. Whether it’s radio, television, Twitter, or Facebook, opinions abound on what to do about the presidential election in November. I typically don’t weigh in on politics. I didn’t plan to weigh in, at least not in this way, in this election either. Yet seemingly daily I find another high profile Evangelical pledging support for Donald Trump. Moreover, I find seemingly hourly someone telling me that a vote for anyone other than Trump is a vote for Hillary. I try to be patient and gracious and recognize the merit in other people’s positions, even when I heartily disagree, but this rhetoric of a vote for another candidate being a vote for Hillary is getting frustrating. I do understand the concern. I do understand that, in general, voting for someone other than Trump makes Hillary’s election more likely. But that does not mean that I have voted for her. The same cannot be said for Evangelicals who support Trump. If he wins, and he is the kind of president I think he would be (it’s not a pretty picture), then they will have to answer for that vote, because they have issued it for him directly and purposefully.
I recently read an editorial by a woman saying that any who fail to vote for Trump and thereby vote for Hillary (there is the false logic again) will give up their right to “be martyrs” when Hillary takes away our rights. No! Because my non-vote for Trump is also a non-vote for Hillary. I may be #neverTrump, but I’m also #neverHillary. If Hillary does what she may do as president, then I can, within the bounds of our Democratic Republic, peacefully yet vocally disagree. By not voting for Trump, I retain the right to do the same if he wins. The author of this editorial fails to recognize that a vote for Trump so that Hillary does not win is (quite literally) a vote for Trump. And if Trump wins and does what I think he would do as president (did I mention it’s not pretty), it is she, not I, who have given up her right to “be a martyr.”
But some would say, “Trump is bad, but Hillary is worse. I think in that case it is better to vote for the lesser of two evils.” Setting aside that this may prove to be an incorrect judgment of character, I find this logic scary as well. As I was reading last night, I came across a poignant passage of prophetic political discourse that motivated me to write these thoughts. The motivation came, as it so often does for me, from a work of fiction—to be more precise, a work of fantasy, or a fairy tale, if you like, by C. S. Lewis. The book is Prince Caspian and the insight is from Nikabrik. If you haven’t read Prince Caspian, or need a bit of a refresher, Nikabrik is a bit of an unsavory character. But this is what made what he says so poignant. No Evangelical I know reads Prince Caspian and says, “That Nikabrik is a wise character worthy of imitation.” And yet, the words I am hearing from many Evangelicals sound eerily similar to Nikabrik’s political philosophy. As the characters involved discuss plans for installing Caspian as king and preparing for war against the Telmarines, Caspian asks Nikabrik if he believes in Aslan. Nikabrik replies, “I’ll believe in anyone or anything that’ll batter these cursed Telmarine barbarians to pieces or drive them out of Narnia. Anyone or anything, Aslan or the White Witch, do you understand?” To Nikabrik, the White Witch is better than the Telmarines because she at least cared (or better, pretended to care, but it is clear she only cared about herself) for the dwarves. Enter Trump and Evangelicals. Somehow many Evangelicals have begun to believe that Trump is better than Hillary because he at least cares (or better, pretends to care, but it is clear he only cares about himself) for the values of Evangelicals.
If a person genuinely wants to vote for Trump because one thinks him a “good candidate with flaws,” then vote for him (though I disagree with his or her character assessment). But if someone wants to vote for Trump as the lesser of two evils, despite serious concerns about his character, simply because they want to avoid the cursed Telmarines (I mean, Democrats), then I urge you to pick up Prince Caspian and imagine how poorly things would have gone if Nikabrik had succeeded in his way. As for me, I won’t be Nikabrik and I will trust in Aslan and vote for the candidate as close to Caspian as I can find, even if he has no chance to win. Who knows, maybe Aslan shows up with the Dryads in our day, too, and brings victory we never could have imagined.